Patient guide

Revision hip and knee replacement: when a prosthesis fails

Revision hip or knee replacement is a second operation to remove and replace some or all of the parts of a joint replacement that has failed, most often because of loosening, wear, infection, instability or a fracture around the implant. It is more complex than a first replacement, so the evaluation is careful and the plan is made case by case with a surgeon trained in adult reconstruction.

Why a hip or knee prosthesis can fail

Most hip and knee replacements work well for many years; national joint registries report that the large majority are still in place 15 to 20 years after surgery. When an implant does fail, the usual causes are:

  • Aseptic loosening. The bond between the implant and the bone weakens over time without infection, and the component begins to move.
  • Polyethylene wear. The plastic bearing surface slowly wears. Wear particles can trigger an inflammatory reaction that dissolves bone around the implant (osteolysis), which can lead to loosening.
  • Infection. Bacteria can reach the joint at the time of surgery or years later through the bloodstream. Periprosthetic joint infection is one of the most serious causes of failure.
  • Instability or dislocation. A hip that dislocates repeatedly, or a knee that feels like it gives way, may have components in a position or of a size that no longer suits the soft tissues.
  • Periprosthetic fracture. A fall or injury can break the bone around the implant.
  • Stiffness. Some knees develop scar tissue and lose motion despite rehabilitation.

You can read more about these complications on our page about the risks of hip and knee replacement.

Symptoms that may mean your joint replacement needs attention

Contact your surgeon if, after a period of doing well, you notice:

  • New or increasing pain in the groin, thigh or knee, especially pain at the start of walking or pain at rest or at night
  • Swelling, warmth or redness around the joint, fever, or a wound that drains
  • A feeling that the hip or knee is unstable, slips or gives way
  • A change in leg length
  • New clicking, grinding or squeaking

Not every new symptom means the implant has failed. Pain can come from the spine, tendons or other causes, which is why a structured evaluation matters.

How a failed hip or knee replacement is evaluated

The goal of the workup is to find out why the joint is failing, because the cause determines the treatment.

  • X-rays. Serial X-rays, ideally compared with earlier films, show loosening, wear, bone loss, implant position and fractures. A CT scan is sometimes added to measure bone loss or component rotation.
  • Blood tests. Inflammatory markers such as ESR (sedimentation rate) and CRP (C-reactive protein) help screen for infection.
  • Joint aspiration. If infection is suspected, fluid is drawn from the joint with a needle and analyzed for cell count and cultures. This is a key step, since an infected joint is treated very differently from one that is loose without infection.

Why revision surgery is more complex than a first replacement

A revision is not simply a repeat of the original operation. It is usually longer and technically more demanding because:

  • Implants must be removed. Well-fixed components and cement have to be taken out while preserving as much bone as possible.
  • Bone loss is common. Loosening, wear and infection can leave defects that need to be reconstructed with augments, bone graft or special components.
  • Specialized components are often needed. Revision stems, cones, sleeves, constrained liners or more constrained knee designs may be required to achieve stable fixation.
  • Infection may require more than one stage. Depending on the situation, an infected joint may be treated with a single operation or with two stages: removal of the implant and placement of an antibiotic spacer, then a new prosthesis once the infection is controlled.

Recovery after revision is usually slower than after a first hip replacement or knee replacement, and the risks are generally higher. Your surgeon will discuss what is realistic in your specific case.

Training in adult reconstruction and revision

Dr. Aria Ravery Morovati completed a fellowship in adult reconstruction at the University of Toronto, Toronto Western Hospital (2024-2025), which covered primary and revision hip and knee replacement and complex reconstruction. He performs revision hip and knee surgery in San Jose and coordinates the national Hip and Knee Replacement Chapter. Learn more on the about page.

What to bring to your consultation

Revision planning depends heavily on information from your first surgery. If possible, bring or send:

  • The operative report from your original replacement
  • The implant stickers or implant record card (manufacturer, model and sizes)
  • Prior X-rays, especially those taken soon after the first surgery, plus any recent imaging
  • Any lab results, culture reports and a list of your medications and medical conditions

If you live outside Costa Rica, a first assessment can be arranged over WhatsApp after you send your imaging and records.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if my hip replacement is failing?

New pain, swelling, a feeling of instability, a change in leg length or new noises after a period of doing well are reasons to be checked. X-rays, blood tests and sometimes a joint aspiration help determine whether the implant is the cause.

Does every failed implant need a full revision?

No. Sometimes only one part, such as the plastic liner or the femoral head, needs to be exchanged. In other cases all components must be replaced. The extent of surgery is decided after the evaluation.

Can revision surgery be done in Costa Rica if my first surgery was abroad?

Yes, as long as the records and imaging are available and the evaluation supports surgery. A personalized estimate is given after reviewing your history and imaging.

When to consult

If you have new pain, swelling or instability in a hip or knee replacement, send your records and X-rays by WhatsApp to +506 7127-5454 or use the contact page. You can also book a consultation online at https://directorio.hilc.cr/en/doctor/aria-alexander-ravery-morovati.

References

  • American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, OrthoInfo: Revision Total Hip Replacement; Revision Total Knee Replacement
  • American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons: Revision Total Hip and Knee Replacement (patient information)
  • Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry, annual report

Medical author

Content reviewed by Dr. Aria Ravery Morovati, orthopedic surgeon and traumatologist (Universidad de Costa Rica), fellowship in hip and knee replacement (University of Toronto, Toronto Western Hospital), San Jose, Costa Rica. Last reviewed: November 2026. Professional profile · Contact. This information is educational and does not replace a medical assessment.

We’re here to help

Book an appointment

Hospital Internacional La Católica  ·  +506 2246-3563  ·  WhatsApp +506 7127-5454
dr.ariaravery@gmail.com

Request a consultation
Dr. Aria Ravery
Orthopedic Surgeon · Hip & knee replacement · Costa Rica
Hospital Internacional La Católica
+506 2246-3563 · WhatsApp +506 7127-5454
Instagram @dr_ariaravery_jointcare
LinkedIn · dr-aria-ravery-ortopedia